Office action · Citations · Response · Paragraph mapping
How to check the paragraphs and figures cited in an office action
The examiner writes "D1, paragraph [0023], Fig. 3" or "col. 3, lines 10-25". What is the fastest way to find that passage and that figure? This guide explains each citation format, what to do when the publication and the granted patent do not line up, and the mistakes people make most often.
In an office action (OA), the examiner usually states which paragraph and which figure of each cited document correspond to which claim. Before responding, the attorney has to check passage by passage whether the examiner's reading holds up. The slowest part of that work is usually flipping back and forth between several cited documents.
Examiners have to point to the passages they rely on
US rules require that when a reference is complex or shows more than the claimed invention, the examiner designates the particular part relied on as nearly as practicable (37 CFR 1.104(c)(2)). In Taiwan, the search report issued by the Taiwan Intellectual Property Office (TIPO) lists the relevant passages of each cited document and the claims they relate to (TIPO, Patent Q&A, substantive examination question 31, in Chinese). Korea's examination guidelines likewise require the examiner to identify the parts of a document that an inventive-step rejection relies on (KIPO Examination Guidelines, Part 5). The paragraph and figure numbers in the OA are therefore the most direct leads you have.
Common citation formats
- [0023], paragraph 23: paragraph numbering is used by US application publications and by most documents from Taiwan, China, Japan and Europe. US rules number paragraphs with at least four digits in square brackets (37 CFR 1.52(b)(6)); in Taiwan, the specification may also be numbered with four consecutive digits in brackets (Enforcement Rules of the Patent Act, Article 17, paragraph 3).
- col. 3, lines 10-25: granted US patents (B1, B2) are printed in columns and lines, so this means column 3, lines 10 to 25.
- Fig. 3: used everywhere; find the figure number on the drawing sheets.
- element 12: a reference sign on a drawing; look up the same sign in the description.
The USPTO's Manual of Patent Examining Procedure also says that electronic documents are cited by paragraph, sentence and, where available, line number (MPEP 707.05(e)).
Matching reference signs to the description
Patent offices require the signs on the drawings to match the description:
- United States: reference characters not mentioned in the description must not appear in the drawings, and those mentioned in the description must appear in the drawings; the same part is always designated by the same character (37 CFR 1.84(p)(4) and (5)).
- Taiwan: the description must include a list of reference signs, ordered by figure or by sign (Enforcement Rules of the Patent Act, Article 17, paragraph 1, item 7); technical terms and signs must be used consistently (Article 22); and drawings must show figure numbers and signs (Article 23).
So you can start from a sign on a drawing, say 12, find what "12" refers to in the list of reference signs or the description, and then check whether it really is the technical feature named in the claim. In Taiwan, claims may cite drawing signs in parentheses, but the signs do not limit how the claim is interpreted (Enforcement Rules, Article 19).
Common mistakes
- Wrong version: the examiner cited the published application while you have the granted patent, or the other way round, so paragraph and column-line numbers do not match. Check the kind code on the number in the OA (for the US, A1, B1 or B2) and use that version.
- Mixing up D1 and D2: when one passage of the OA cites several documents, "Fig. 3" may belong to D2. Confirm which document each citation refers to.
- Different paragraph numbers in the original and the translation: in Taiwan, TIPO states that the foreign-language text and the Chinese translation do not need to share paragraph numbers (Patent Q&A, application procedure question 51). When checking against a translation, go by the version the examiner cited.
- Reading paragraphs but not drawings: many technical features only become clear in the drawings, and the reference signs are what connect the description to the figures.
How to do it faster
The manual setups we see most often: two or even three monitors with the OA and every cited PDF open at once, or the OA and each reference printed out and spread across the desk. When the OA says "D1, paragraph [0023], Fig. 3", you switch to D1, scroll to the paragraph, then go to the drawing sheets to find Fig. 3; the next sentence cites D2 and you start over. With three or four references of several dozen pages each, most of the time goes into finding things rather than judging whether the examiner's reading is right.
That is why we built the OA Smart Reader: it puts the office action, the cited text and the drawings side by side on one screen. Click a paragraph number, figure number or reference sign in the OA and it jumps straight to that passage and that figure in the cited document, with no window switching or paper flipping. The reader also shows why it matched each citation to a particular patent, so you can confirm it on the spot. You can try the sample OA without signing up.
If the references are not downloaded yet, start with How to download every reference cited in an office action.